Sign Up for Email Alerts Visit us on Twitter Visit us on Facebook Visit us on YouTube Subscribe to RSS Feeds

Home > Past Briefings > Briefing Detail Page

Briefing Detail Page

Change Text Size:   Smaller Text Size   Larger Text Size   Default Text Size    

Public Plan Option: Fair Competition or a Recipe for Crowd-Out?

Monday, April 27, 2009

One of the various proposals to expand coverage to the more than 45 million uninsured Americans is referred to as the “public plan option.” Though proposed only as part of a broader effort to expand coverage, the option is viewed in varying lights. Some see it as a tool for providing consumers affordable coverage by stimulating competition on the basis of quality and efficiency. Others see it as unfair competition for private insurers and, in the extreme, as a path to a single-payer system.

What is actually meant by a public plan and how would it work? Is there evidence of fair competition from public plans? Might private plans outperform a public option? What are some examples of private systems today that are delivering quality care efficiently? What can we learn about crowd-out from state initiatives? Would individual and employer mandates make the plan more palatable?

To address these and related questions, the Alliance for Health Reform and The Commonwealth Fund sponsored an April 27 briefing. Panelists were Karen Davis, president of The Commonwealth Fund; Karen Ignagni, president of America’s Health Insurance Plans; John Holahan, Urban Institute; and Stuart Butler, The Heritage Foundation. Ed Howard of the Alliance moderated.


 Ed Howard, Alliance for Health Reform, Moderator
 Karen Davis, The Commonwealth Fund, Speaker
 Karen Ignagni, America's Health Insurance Plans, Speaker
 John Holahan, Urban Institute, Speaker
 Stuart Butler, The Heritage Foundation, Speaker
(Click on the camera icon to see a video of the speaker's presentation.)

Transcript, Event Summary and/or Webcast and Podcast

Transcript: Public Plan Option: Fair Competition or a Recipe for Crowd-Out? (Adobe Acrobat PDF), 4/27/2009
Event Summary: Public Plan Option: Fair Competition or a Recipe for Crowd-Out? (Word Document), 4/27/2009
Full Webcast/Podcast: Public Plan Option: Fair Competition or a Recipe for Crowd-Out?

The full webcast and podcast for this briefing, as well as videos of individual speakers' presentations, are provided by Kaiser Family Foundation.

Speaker Presentations

Karen Davis Presentation (PowerPoint), 4/27/2009
Karen Ignagni Presentation (PowerPoint), 4/27/2009
John Holahan Presentation (PowerPoint), 4/27/2009
Stuart Butler Presentation (PowerPoint), 4/27/2009

(If you want to download one or more slides from these presentations, contact us at info@allhealth or click here for instructions.)

Source Materials

Agenda (Word Document), , 4/27/2009
Speaker Biographies (Word Document), , 4/27/2009
Selected Experts (Word Document), , 4/27/2009
Public Plan Option: Fair Competition or a Recipe for Crowd-Out? (Word Document), , 4/27/2009
Panelist Responses to Written Questions (Adobe Acrobat PDF), , 4/27/2009

Offsite Materials (briefing documents saved on other websites)

A Government-Run “Public” Health Insurance Plan: Why Doctors, Hospitals, and Patients Will Lose (Adobe Acrobat PDF),U.S. Senate Republican Policy Committee, 3/24/2009
A Health Plan for All and the Concerns Its Raises, New York Times, 3/25/2009
A Lesson on Health Care From Massachusetts, The New York Times, 3/29/2009
A Modest Proposal for a Competing Public Health Plan, New America Foundation, 3/1/2009
Aetna Fights Public Health Plan as Industry Offers a Concession , Bloomberg, 3/24/2009
Can a Public Insurance Plan Increase Competition and Lower the Costs of Health Reform? (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Urban Institute, 10/8/2008
Competitive Health Care: A Public Health Insurance Plan that Delivers Market Discipline (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Center for American Progress Action Fund, 3/1/2009
Health Reform Without a Public Plan: The German Model, The New York Times, 4/17/2009
Health-Care Battle Set to Focus on Public Plan, The Wall Street Journal, 3/24/2009
How a Public Health Plan Will Erode Private Care (Adobe Acrobat PDF),The Heritage Foundation , 12/22/2008
Obama Aide Sees Public Health Plan as Part of Reform, The Washington Post, 4/15/2009
Pricing a Medicare-Like Public Health Plan, New York Times, 4/10/2009
Stakeholders start offering their own proposals for health reform, American Medical Association, 4/6/2009
The Cost and Coverage Impacts of a Public Plan: Alternative Design Options (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Lewin Group, 4/6/2009
The Path to a High Performance U.S Health System, The Commonwealth Fund, 3/1/2009
Healthy Competition: How to Structure Public Health Insurance Plan Choice to Ensure... (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Institute for America’s Future, 4/1/2009
The End of Private Health Insurance. Not., The New Republic , 4/13/2009
CPC Letter to Democratic Leadership (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Congressional Progressive Causus, 4/2/2009
Butler: Perils of a Public Health Plan, The Washington Times, 3/26/2009
Ensuring Access to Affordable Health Insurance (Adobe Acrobat PDF),The Heritage Foundation, 12/2/2008
How a Public Health Plan Will Erode Private Care (Adobe Acrobat PDF),The Heritage Foundation , 12/22/2008
Massachusetts Health Reform: Solving the Long-Run Cost Problem (Adobe Acrobat PDF),Urban Institute, 1/1/2009


Uwe Reinhardt Questions Bundled Payment Savings Prospects

Video (2:58)

A new Alliance for Health Reform video features Princeton’s Uwe Reinhardt questioning whether bundling payments for medical services might actually lead to higher – not lower – costs.

"The ACO's, the accountable care organizations, could create local monopolies that could dictate to you what that bundled price would be, and some of us fear that bundled prices might be even more than what the fee-for-service for that bundle would be today. … You really should align all the payers and say, 'Let us jointly negotiate with the ACOs what those bundles should be so that they cannot divide and rule and sort of make us on the buy side weak.'"


Read More 

Sister Carol Keehan on Health Law Enrollment Challenges this Year

Video 3:00

A new Alliance for Health Reform video features Sister Carol Keehan of the Catholic Health Association of the United States addressing the challenges of quickly enrolling millions of Americans for health insurance this fall. Open season begins October 1 of this year, yet she says that up to 85 percent of those who will be newly eligible for Medicaid or for subsidies to buy private insurance in state-based exchanges don't know it.  FULL TRANSCRIPT

Read More 

Jonathan Blum on CMS Efforts to Keep Medicare Spending Growth Down

Video (2:54)

Jonathan Blum, acting principal deputy administrator and director of the Center for Medicare at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), addresses the slower growth of Medicare spending over the last few years, and what his agency is doing to try and continue the trend. “There are promising signs that this strategy to change the payment system, to change the payment models, to focus on waste and abuse, is paying off," he said. "We are taking a whole new approach to addressing fraud in the program. Much more data resources, much more on the ground reaction. We have seen dramatic spending declines in areas of spending, such as home health and durable medical supplies that historically fueled lots of the fraud.”  FULL TRANSCRIPT

Read More 

Two Former Medicare Administrators Discuss How to Save the Program

A new Alliance for Health Reform video features two former Medicare administrators -- Gail Wilensky and Bruce Vladeck -- on their ideas about how to save the program.

Ms. Wilensky, who ran Medicare in a Republican administration, argued for increasing the eligibility age of Medicare for future retirees, while still making the program available at age 65 for those who are disabled.

Watch at

Read More 

Douglas Holtz-Eakin: Health Care Spending Lull Only Temporary

Video (3:11)

A new Alliance for Health Reform video features Douglas Holtz-Eakin of the American Action Forum, and a former director of the Congressional Budget Office, arguing that recent slower spending growth in health care won’t continue.

"We also saw a slowdown in the mid-90s, and we all declared victory and it came right back. I think next year we’ll see a noticeable uptick. There will be lots of new people entering the insurance markets because of the exchanges and the subsidies that come along with them, and those subsidies are very generous. … These are an invitation for people to get coverage and to buy more health care. I think that’ll place a lot of pressure on spending."


Read More 

Marketplace Enrollment Helpers Toolkit

Beginning October 1, insurance marketplaces open for enrollment, and millions of people will be eligible to purchase plans. To guide them in the application process, the federal government has invested in programs to train community organizations and hired staff.

Read More 

The Employer Mandate of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

The Toolkit, available here, details the ACA’s employer requirements and penalty. It also includes information about the delay in the mandate to 2015, and analysis about its impact on employer-based coverage.

Read More 

Toolkit: Training the Workforce for a Changing Health System

A new Alliance for Health Reform toolkit addresses concerns about whether newly-trained physicians are adequately prepared for today's evolving health care delivery system. Does training adequately emphasize care coordination, team-based care, costs of care, health information technology, cultural competence and quality improvement? Does it encourage students to practice in a primary care setting?

Read More 

Toolkit: Emergency Preparedness in the U.S.: The Ebola Threat

Is the U.S. prepared for a potential virulent pandemic? This new Alliance toolkit examines public health infrastructure, funding and policy levers that deal with these kinds of health crises in America.

Read More 

Copyright 1997-2014 Alliance for Health Reform
1444 Eye Street, NW, Suite 910 Washington, DC 20005-6573      202-789-2300      202-789-2233 fax      Sitemap